Copytrade Press

Copied trades, checked twice

NewsCopy TradingRegulationDisclosure

Is copy trading safe? Five risks IOSCO names

Is copy trading safe? Not as a blanket answer. Five risks from IOSCO's 2025 report, each set against what eToro and Bybit print on their own pages.

By Staff, Copytrade Press

Is copy trading safe? Not in any general sense. It carries the risks of whatever is being traded, and copying adds its own. The securities regulators’ body IOSCO, in a May 2025 report, names losses from leveraged products, fees from frequent trading, unsuitable strategies, conflicts of interest and scams. Platform controls narrow some of these. None we read removes them.

That is an answer in parts, because safe is not one question. This is an evergreen explainer with no news behind it. The report has a date; the percentages and settings below do not stay put, so each is what a page showed when this desk read it on 6 November 2026, and nothing more.

Where do these five copy trading risks come from?

IOSCO is the International Organization of Securities Commissions. Its Final Report on online imitative trading practices, FR/06/2025, draws on a survey of regulators. This desk read it through search windows on a text copy, not end to end, because the PDF refused a direct request.

Five is our selection, not the report’s count. The report also raises track records nobody has independently verified and the growing overlap with finfluencers. It sets out Good Practices too, which it calls guidance that may be helpful to IOSCO members and market intermediaries. Guidance is not law, and nothing here treats those practices as adopted anywhere.

Is copy trading safe? Five risks against two platforms’ pages

Each row sets a risk from the report against what two platforms print. Read the platform columns as description, not endorsement: this post calls no firm authorised or regulated, and it recommends nobody to copy. “Not read” means this desk did not reach the text, not that the page lacks it.

Risk, per IOSCOeToro, pages readBybit, Classic follower guideWhat stays with you
Losses from leveraged productsCopy Stop-Loss, default 40%, adjustable from 5% to 95%. Warning: 55% of retail accounts lose money on CFDsGuide covers copying Futures trades, with leverage and TP/SL sections. Loss figure: not readThe positions are yours, and so are the losses
Fee erosion from frequent tradingNo extra charge to copy; spreads and/or transaction fees still applyProfit share, 10% in the guide’s example. Trading fees: not readThe lead trader sets the pace of trading
Strategy out of line with your ability to bear lossesRisk score from 1 to 10, primarily historical price volatilityFollower parameters, unavailable if the Master Trader enables Forced SyncOnly you know what you can afford to lose
Lead-trader conflicts of interestUp to 1.5% of assets under copy, paid monthly, Champion tier and above; tier table marks 1.5% as annual on some tiersProfit-sharing ratio shown before copying, varying by Master Trader levelYou do not set the pay formula
Scams labelled copy tradingNo setting on the pages read addresses thisNo setting on the pages read addresses thisChecking who is taking your money

The steps of Bybit’s guide are in our walk-through of how to start copy trading.

How do leveraged products hurt a copier?

The report’s executive summary says copy trading can expose retail investors to significant risks, leveraged-product losses first among those it names. It adds elsewhere that volatile markets and leveraged products may heighten the risk of cumulative losses over time.

A copy puts that exposure in your account in proportion. eToro’s CopyTrader page says positions are duplicated automatically, in real time and direct proportion, and it carries a warning that 55% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with the provider. That figure covers all of its retail CFD accounts on the edition this desk was served, not copiers alone, and a printed figure can change.

The control worth reading slowly is Copy Stop-Loss. eToro’s page sets it by default at 40% of the invested amount, adjustable between 5% and 95%. Its worked example treats the percentage as the level equity falls to, not the size of the loss: 60% of $1,000 is $600, and the copy closes when equity reaches $600. On that example’s logic, the default on $1,000 closes at $400, which is a $600 loss. A 40% default is not a 40% limit. The text this desk read ended partway through that section, so nothing here says whether a close can fill below the level. Whether a loss can exceed the sum invested is a separate question, answered in its own post.

Why do frequent trades erode copied returns?

The second risk is arithmetic. The report names erosion of returns through high transaction fees from frequent trading. Copying hands your account someone else’s trading frequency, and the costs of that frequency come with it.

eToro’s CopyTrader page says there is no additional charge for copying, and in the next sentence that spreads and/or transaction fees still apply where applicable. Free to copy and free to run are different claims. Its how-it-works page notes that a new copy may show a slight initial loss, which reflects the spread.

Bybit’s guide adds a second layer. If a Master Trader’s profit-sharing ratio is 10%, followers share 10% of the profit earned from copying that trader. The house question still applies to any return displayed beside it: measured over what period, counting whom, after which costs? The windows this desk read on the two platforms did not say whether their displayed returns are net of these charges.

Can a copied strategy be wrong for you?

Yes, and this risk is structural. The report says that imitating trades automatically, without active monitoring or intervention, can lead retail investors into strategies out of line with their financial situation, including their ability to bear losses, and their objectives, including risk tolerance. It says losses can be significant, especially where lead traders run high-risk strategies or fail to disclose risks and costs adequately.

eToro offers a risk score from 1 (very low) to 10 (extreme). Its help page says the score primarily measures historical price volatility and may not capture all types of investment risk. A score describes a portfolio’s past. It knows nothing about your circumstances.

Controls can also be narrower than the headline. eToro’s CopyTrader page says funds can be added or removed at any time. Its how-it-works page says that during what it calls reallocation you cannot add or withdraw funds, close individual positions or pause the copy, and that the process takes up to 7 business days. On Bybit, the parameters under More Settings are unavailable if the Master Trader enables Forced Sync. In both cases the setting comes with a condition.

The report adds that the perceived credibility of lead traders can obscure the true level of risk, particularly where their qualifications or track records are not independently verified. A leaderboard is not a verification.

Whose interests does the lead trader serve?

The report says that in certain circumstances lead traders may put their own interests ahead of copiers’, for example when they receive incentives for investing in specific products or using specific platforms. Separately, certain respondents, not IOSCO itself, noted a potential conflict where lead traders are paid on the volume of copiers’ trades.

The two platforms’ pay lines read differently. eToro’s Pro Investor page, headed Get Copied, Get Paid, offers a payment of up to 1.5% of assets under copy, paid monthly at Champion tier and above, marks 1.5% as annual on some tiers of its table, and says only program members can be copied. That line ties pay to the money copied. Bybit’s guide describes a share of followers’ profit, with a ratio that varies by the Master Trader’s level. Neither line, as read, is the volume arrangement the respondents described, and neither settles whether a conflict exists; that turns on detail beyond those lines. We set out what is published in what eToro pays the trader you copy.

Is a copy trading scam the same as copy trading?

Often not, on the FCA position the report records. The FCA cautioned that scam activity reported as copy trading has often been investment management using Multi Account Manager or Percentage Allocation Management Model arrangements. It said it believed much of the scam activity involves finfluencers promoting others or operating as unregulated FX educators and signal sellers, and it describes consumers being drawn into online chatrooms, where the pitch can turn into Multi Account Manager accounts sold on promises of unrealistic returns.

The report dates the FCA statement to 9 February 2023, while the FCA’s live page now shows a last update of 27 July 2026, so the FCA’s current words should be read there. France supplies a number: the report’s table records 22 complaints to the AMF from 1 January 2021 that turned out to be scams, with copy trading linked most of the time to trading training.

None of the platform settings described above addresses this row. A stop-loss is no use against someone who already holds your money. The check is a different one: who is asking for the money, and may they lawfully manage it where you live? For UK readers, the FCA’s site points to its Firm Checker and its Warning List.

Does regulation make copy trading safe?

Classification is not protection from loss. The FCA’s copy trading page says it classifies copy trading as portfolio or investment management where no manual input is clear from the account holder, which entails standard regulatory obligations for authorised management. The page also says it supports the view in ESMA’s MiFID Questions and Answers on how copy and mirror trading fit within the directive. That test applies to a class of activity. It says nothing about a named firm, and what the label means by jurisdiction is covered in is copy trading legal.

The report records a limit as well. Most jurisdictions reporting copy trading said it is offered on a cross-border basis by a small number of firms, and many observed that authorities have no supervisory or enforcement powers outside their own jurisdiction. A rule can be real and still be someone else’s. Availability and protections vary by where you live.

Frequently asked questions

Is copy trading safe for someone with no trading experience?

No safer than for anyone else. A beginner faces the same risks. Survey respondents told IOSCO that copying may give inexperienced clients a route to a more experienced trader’s strategies, but the report warns that imitating trades automatically, without active monitoring, can produce positions out of line with a person’s ability to bear losses. Automation does not replace knowing what you hold.

What are the risks and benefits of using copy trading as a trading strategy?

The benefits regulators and respondents gave IOSCO were wider retail participation, possible educational value and, depending on the lead trader, improved returns. The risks set out here are leveraged losses, fee erosion, unsuitable strategies, lead-trader conflicts and scams. Note the grammar: the report’s benefits are possible and conditional, while it calls the risks significant.

Copy trading, what’s the catch?

The catch is that you carry the outcome of decisions you did not make. eToro’s CopyTrader page says copying does not amount to investment advice and that capital is at risk, while its Pro Investor page pays copied traders on terms you do not set. The convenience is real. So is the fact that the losses land in your account, not theirs.

The short version

Safe is the wrong unit. Leverage, costs, fit and conflicts are risks inside copy trading; scams are a risk wearing its name. The platform controls described here narrow the first group at best, and none of them addresses the last. You can lose the money you put in, and a lead trader’s past results do not predict yours. Copy trading transfers risk, not skill. Nothing here is financial advice or a suggestion to copy anyone.